“We will support entrepreneurs, back small businesses, and reform business rates to help our high streets.”
Both supporting and contradicting evidence exist — the promise is partially fulfilled.
2025-12-02 · Ayes: 327, Noes: 182
Limiting agricultural and business property reliefs increases inheritance tax on family businesses and farms, directly undermining the manifesto promise to 'back small businesses.' Family-run enterprises are a core part of small business support, and this tax change makes it harder for families to pass businesses to the next generation.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2025-11-04 · Ayes: 106, Noes: 321
The opposition motion directly called for stronger government action to support struggling high streets, which aligns precisely with the manifesto promise to 'reform business rates to help our high streets.' Voting Aye would have advanced this specific commitment to high street support.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2025-09-02 · Ayes: 365, Noes: 164
Devolving powers to local areas could theoretically support local business development and high street regeneration, but the division description does not specify whether devolved powers would include business rate reform or targeted small business support. The connection is too speculative without concrete details.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2025-09-02 · Ayes: 167, Noes: 367
The English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill devolves powers to local areas, which could theoretically support local businesses and high streets. However, the division description does not specify whether devolved powers would include business rate reform or small business support, making the connection too indirect to establish reliably.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2025-06-10 · Ayes: 306, Noes: 174
While planning reform could indirectly affect business development and high street regeneration, the division description provides no specific details about how the bill's final form would impact small businesses or high streets. Without concrete information on the bill's provisions, the connection remains too speculative.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2025-05-21 · Ayes: 88, Noes: 253
While this opposition day debate concerned business and the economy broadly, the division description provides no specific details about which economic policies or business measures were debated. Without knowing whether the motion addressed business rates, small business support, or other matters covered by the promise, the connection cannot be reliably established.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2025-04-24 · Ayes: 88, Noes: 212
This vote concerns parliamentary oversight of emergency banking powers during financial crises. It is unrelated to the manifesto's specific commitments to support small businesses, entrepreneurs, or reform business rates for high streets.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2025-04-24 · Ayes: 89, Noes: 230
The Bank Resolution Bill concerns emergency powers to recapitalise failing banks during financial crises. This is a systemic financial stability measure unrelated to the manifesto's specific commitments to support small businesses, entrepreneurs, or reform business rates for high streets.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2025-03-24 · Ayes: 330, Noes: 74
While planning reform could indirectly affect business development and high street regeneration, the division description provides no specific details about how the bill would impact small businesses or high streets. The connection is too speculative without knowing the bill's concrete provisions affecting the manifesto's specific commitments.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2025-02-26 · Ayes: 108, Noes: 313
The opposition motion focused on family businesses, likely addressing concerns about recent tax changes affecting family-run enterprises. Since the government rejected this motion and family businesses are a subset of small businesses covered by the manifesto promise to 'back small businesses,' voting Aye would have supported protections for family businesses that the government opposed.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-12-17 · Ayes: 196, Noes: 352
This amendment to the National Insurance Contributions Bill was defeated, allowing the government's increase in employer National Insurance contributions to proceed. This tax increase on employers directly contradicts the manifesto promise to 'support entrepreneurs, back small businesses,' as it increases the cost of employing workers for small business owners.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-12-17 · Ayes: 195, Noes: 353
The amendment sought to require an impact assessment of how the employer National Insurance increase affects different business sectors and employment. Voting Aye would have supported scrutiny of a policy that harms small businesses. The government's rejection of this assessment requirement undermines transparency about the impact on small business support.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-12-17 · Ayes: 206, Noes: 353
This amendment to the National Insurance Contributions Bill was defeated, meaning the government's increase in employer National Insurance contributions proceeded unchanged. This tax increase on employers directly contradicts the manifesto promise to 'support entrepreneurs, back small businesses,' as higher employer taxes burden small business owners.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-12-04 · Ayes: 165, Noes: 334
The opposition motion criticised the government's increase in employers' National Insurance contributions, arguing it would harm small businesses. Voting Aye would have opposed this tax increase on employers. The manifesto promise to 'support entrepreneurs, back small businesses' is undermined by higher employer taxes, making this division directly contradictory to the promise's intent.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-11-06 · Ayes: 454, Noes: 124
This vote concerns tax relief for investment spending by oil and gas companies under the energy profits levy. It is unrelated to supporting small businesses, entrepreneurs, or reforming business rates for high streets, which are the specific commitments in the manifesto promise.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-11-06 · Ayes: 455, Noes: 125
The energy profits levy targets oil and gas companies' exceptional profits and is unrelated to supporting small businesses, entrepreneurs, or high street reform. While it affects the broader business environment, it does not materially advance or undermine the specific manifesto commitments to small business support or business rate reform.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-11-06 · Ayes: 400, Noes: 122
Investors' relief on capital gains tax affects investment returns for shareholders and investors, but is not directly related to supporting small businesses, entrepreneurs, or reforming business rates for high streets. The connection to the manifesto promise is too indirect and concerns a different class of taxpayer.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-11-06 · Ayes: 400, Noes: 120
Business asset disposal relief is a tax break for entrepreneurs and business owners selling their companies. The manifesto promise to 'support entrepreneurs' is directly advanced by maintaining or supporting this relief. Voting Aye on the budget resolution approving this relief supports the promise's commitment to back entrepreneurs.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-11-06 · Ayes: 401, Noes: 120
Increasing the main rate of capital gains tax affects investors and business owners selling assets, but the manifesto promise focuses on supporting small businesses and reforming business rates. While capital gains tax can affect business succession, the connection is indirect and the division does not specifically address small business support or high street reform.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
2024-10-16 · Ayes: 80, Noes: 337
This opposition day debate concerned access to primary healthcare and GP services, which is entirely separate from the manifesto promise to support small businesses and reform business rates. There is no meaningful connection between healthcare policy and the business-focused commitments.
Reviewed by Tomasz Mikuś
{
"reason": "Both supporting and contradicting evidence exist — the promise is partially fulfilled.",
"newStatus": "partial",
"previousStatus": "kept"
}{
"reason": "Supporting weight ≥ 0.5 with no contradicting evidence — the promise is fulfilled.",
"newStatus": "kept",
"previousStatus": "not_yet_tested"
}See an error? Report an issue